Submetering vs. RUBS for California Manufactured Housing Communities

“RUBS” and “submetering” are the two ways properties with many homes turn one master utility bill into many resident bills. In most of the rental world, choosing between them is a business decision. In California manufactured housing, it is substantially a legal one — and since 2022, the law has moved decisively toward measured, bill-derived charges. This guide explains both methods, then walks through what California's Mobilehome Residency Law and Public Utilities Code actually permit.

What Is RUBS?

RUBS — Ratio Utility Billing System — divides a property's master utility bill among residents by formula instead of by meter. Common formulas allocate by square footage, by number of occupants, or as a fixed equal share per home. Nothing is measured at the individual space; each resident pays a calculated fraction of the property's total.

RUBS exists because retrofitting meters costs money and some utility configurations make individual metering hard. Its weakness is inherent: a resident's bill has no relationship to what that resident actually used. A single space with a leak, a pool fill, or heavy usage is subsidized by every other space on the formula.

What Is Submetering?

Submetering puts a meter on each space behind the property's master meter. The serving utility bills the property on the master meter; the operator (or a billing provider) reads each submeter and bills each resident for measured consumption. Every charge traces to an opening read, a closing read, and a rate.

Many California manufactured housing communities built with master-metered utilities were built with submeters — the configuration the Mobilehome Residency Law's billing rules are written around.

The Comparison

RUBSSubmetering
Basis of each billFormula share of the master billMeasured consumption at the space
FairnessHigh users subsidized by low usersEach resident pays for their own usage
Conservation incentiveNone — usage doesn't change the billDirect — usage is the bill
Dispute defensibilityDepends entirely on the formula's documentationMeter reads on the bill; independently verifiable
California MH water/sewerNot a method once water is submetered; where no submeters exist, permitted within § 798.41's limits (our reading of § 798.41(a)), with no safe harbor (see below)The method the statute is written around

What California Law Says for Manufactured Housing

Two bodies of law govern here. For water, manufactured housing has its own rules; for gas and electric, the same rate-parity rule applies to apartments too.

Water and sewer: only the statute's methods

Since AB 1061 (Cal. Civ. Code § 798.40(c), operative January 1, 2022) — and, since AB 604 (operative January 1, 2024), also where the water company or the community is regulated by the CPUC (§ 798.40(f)) — management “shall only bill” submetered water service using the methods the statute lists — a metered share of the community's own water bill, each tier's volume divided evenly among the spaces, or the water company's own per-space rates as charged to the community, plus the purveyor's fixed charges shared by usage or equally among spaces (§ 798.40(c)(1)–(2)). Occupancy-based, square-footage, and fixed-ratio (RUBS-style) allocation have no statutory safe harbor for water and sewer in this setting. The administrative fee is capped by § 798.40(c)(3). Under the proportional method (§ 798.40(c)(1)(A)), each resident's usage charge is a share of the purveyor's usage dollars in proportion to metered use, so together they never exceed them; under every method, common-area water and others' use stay out (§ 798.40(c)(1)(D)). Under the per-space tier method residents' usage charges together can exceed the purveyor's usage dollars, because heavy use prices into the higher per-space tiers — no statute caps the sum.

Gas and electric: direct-service rate parity

Cal. Pub. Util. Code § 739.5(a) requires a master-meter customer to charge each user “at the same rate that would be applicable if the user were receiving gas or electricity, or both, directly” from the serving utility. Billing a resident as if served directly requires knowing what that resident consumed — which is what a submeter does. A formula share of the master bill does not produce a rate-parity bill, so gas and electricity from investor-owned utilities (including community-choice electricity) are billed from submeters (our reading of § 739.5(a) and the utility's resale rules; at a city-owned utility such as LADWP, its own rules govern — LADWP Rule 18.D); billed at direct rates, residents' charges can total more than the master bill — that is lawful; the master-meter discount is the community's compensation.

For the core rules — meter readings on the bill, CARE/FERA passthrough, itemization, disclosures, and the rest — see the core California rules.

The Decision, Honestly Framed

For a California manufactured housing community, this is not really a RUBS-vs-submetering choice the way it is for an apartment operator in another state:

  • If your spaces are submetered — bill from the meters. It is the lawful path, the fairer path, and the defensible one in a dispute.
  • If some utilities are master-metered without submeters — the lawful options are narrower than the general-rental playbook suggests, especially for water. Divided water or sewer charges trace to the property's actual bill, common-area usage is excluded, and the total never exceeds that bill (our reading of § 798.41(a)); gas and electricity from investor-owned utilities (including community-choice electricity) cannot be billed by formula at all (Cal. Pub. Util. Code § 739.5(a) and the utility's resale rules); at a city-owned utility such as LADWP, its own rules govern (LADWP Rule 18.D). Get the specific configuration reviewed before choosing a method.
  • If a billing provider is proposing RUBS for water in a California manufactured housing community — ask whether your spaces are submetered (if they are, § 798.40(c)'s methods apply), whether your rental agreement provides otherwise, and how it traces to your water bill, excludes common areas and never exceeds it (§ 798.41).

Frequently Asked Questions

Does RUBS save money over submetering?

RUBS avoids meter installation and reading costs — that is its whole appeal. But in California manufactured housing, avoided hardware cost does not change what the statute permits for water and sewer, and a billing method that cannot survive a resident dispute is not cheap.

Our community has always billed this way. Doesn't that count?

For submetered water, the rules changed on January 1, 2022, and again on January 1, 2024. Practices that were lawful before those dates are not grandfathered: a submetered water bill issued under an old method after the operative dates needs to move to one of the statute's methods.

What about trash or other flat services?

Flat pass-through services like trash are different from RUBS: the charge is not a formula share of a metered utility but a documented amount actually assessed for the service. Cal. Civ. Code § 798.41(d) requires it to be separately stated, and it is limited to what the provider charged — or, for a service the community provides itself, a reasonable charge for a service actually rendered (§ 798.31). See the flat-charges section (B4) of the rules guide.

Want a second look at your statements?

Send us one month of one community's statements and its utility bills, and we'll check every charge against the rates and rules that apply, then walk you through what we found. Free, no obligation.

Request a free bill check